Here’s Why a Silver Price Crash Below $40 Would Be Hard for Bulls to Explain

Silver traded above $120 an ounce at its peak. Now even $50 has slipped away, and one of the more optimistic outcomes Fthegurus can see is that silver manages to stay roughly where it is. The analyst believes the 2025 rally can still leave investors with something lasting, but that case gets harder to make below $40.

The weekly chart Fthegurus shared shows silver at $45.87, about 13% above a move down to $40 in percentage terms from the chart price. Buyers have already made two attempts at a recovery. The first carried silver back above $80. The next ran out of steam near $70. By the time silver fell through $50, it had given back much of the advance that took it from under $40 to triple digits.

Can Industrial Demand Put a Floor Under Silver?

Industrial demand was a popular explanation for the rally. The argument was simple enough. Manufacturers still needed silver as the price rose, and their orders would help support the market when investors sold. Fthegurus questions how much protection those buyers actually offered.

By the analyst’s estimate, silver could lose more than $1 trillion in market value over 11 months if the price falls through $40.

Source: X/@fthegurus

There’s a limit to what that figure can tell us. A lower price reduces the estimated value of silver already in existence. It tells us very little about how many ounces factories bought over the same period. Manufacturers could keep buying at a steady pace and still buy too little to absorb all the silver investors want to sell. A break below $40 would put the claim that industrial buyers can defend that price under pressure. Factory orders are a separate question.

Fthegurus also raises a practical concern for large funds. A manager who bought silver near $50 on the way up could have watched it more than double, held through the decline and ended up underwater. For an institution looking for protection against a weaker dollar, the analyst believes that kind of ride makes gold the easier choice.

Read also: Silver Price Prediction: Peter Brandt Says Low $30s Are Possible

What Would a Win for Silver Bulls Look Like?

Fthegurus would count a sustained trading range between $40 and $55 as a win. A couple of years ago, the comparable range was $20 to $30. If buyers repeatedly step in around $40 and silver works its way back toward $55, even the bottom of its new range would be well above the top of the old one.

That would give bulls a credible case for the 2025 rally without asking anyone to believe in $300 silver by summer.

A fall through $40 would weaken that case. Below $30, the verdict would be tougher still. Silver would be back in its old trading range, and investors who called the 2025 rally a lasting change would have to explain what, exactly, had lasted.

For more financial news and price predictions, click here.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel for daily crypto updates, market insights, and expert analysis.

Tags:

Petar Jovanović
Petar Jovanović

As the Head of Content at Captainaltcoin, I bring years of experience in the crypto industry. With a strong belief in the potential of the web3 market since 2017, I'm passionate about sharing valuable insights and knowledge. Feel free to connect with me on LinkedIn and let's discuss the exciting world of cryptocurrencies and decentralized technologies!

pepeto
CaptainAltcoin
Logo